Comprehensive in silico CpG methylation analysis in hepatocellular carcinoma identifies tissue- and tumor-type specific marks disconnected from gene expression

DNA methylation is crucial for chromatin structure, transcription regulation and genome stability, defining cellular identity. Aberrant hypermethylation of CpG-rich regions is common in cancer, influencing gene expression. However, the specific contributions of individual epigenetic modifications to tumorigenesis remain under investigation. In hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), DNA methylation alterations are documented as in other tumor types. We aimed to identify hypermethylated CpGs in HCC, assess their specificity across other tumor types, and investigate their impact on gene expression. To this end, public methylomes from HCC, other liver diseases, and 27 tumor types as well as expression data from TCGA-LIHC and GTEx were analyzed. This study identified 39 CpG sites that were hypermethylated in HCC compared to control liver tissue, and were located within promoter, gene bodies, and intergenic CpG islands. Notably, these CpGs were predominantly unmethylated in healthy liver tissue and other normal tissues. Comparative analysis with 27 other tumors revealed both common and HCC-specific hypermethylated CpGs. Interestingly, the HCC-hypermethylated genes showed minimal expression in the different healthy tissues, with marginal changes in the level of expression in the corresponding tumors. These findings confirm previous evidence on the limited influence of DNA hypermethylation on gene expression regulation in cancer. It also highlights the existence of mechanisms that allow the selection of tissue-specific methylation marks in normally unexpressed genes during carcinogenesis. Overall, our study contributes to demonstrate the complexity of cancer epigenetics, emphasizing the need of better understanding the interplay between DNA methylation, gene expression dynamics, and tumorigenesis. Graphical Abstract: (Figure presented.)