Skip to Main Content (Press Enter)

Logo UNISR
  • ×
  • Home
  • People
  • Outputs
  • Organizations
  • Expertise & Skills
  • Equipment

UNIFIND
Logo UNISR

|

UNIFIND

unisr.it
  • ×
  • Home
  • People
  • Outputs
  • Organizations
  • Expertise & Skills
  • Equipment
  1. Outputs

Speed and contextual information of a crime-related video bias the responsibility judgments

Academic Article
Publication Date:
2024
Short description:
Speed and contextual information of a crime-related video bias the responsibility judgments / Ribatti, R.M., Lanciano, T., De'Sperati, C., Curci, A.. - In: CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY. - ISSN 1046-1310. - 43:31(2024), pp. 25403-25413. [10.1007/s12144-024-06232-w]
abstract:
Courts often rely on video evidence, assuming it accurately shows important legal details. Yet, studies suggest that video isn’t inherently “objective” and people, including legal professionals, might misinterpret its objectivity due to video quality or context. This study aimed to explore how video speed variations and contextual information affect judgments of responsibility in a video portraying a bus assault. The study employed a 5 × 3 mixed design, with video speed (Very Slow, 0.88x; Slow, 0.96x; Neutral, 1.00x; Fast, 1.04x; Very Fast, 1.12x) as a between-subject variable, contextual information (Hit, Harm, Kill) attributed to the perpetrator’s action as a within-subject factor, and dimensions of accountability, predictability, criminal intent, and severity as dependent variables. ANOVA results from a sample of 300 participants (60 per video speed condition) revealed that the highest levels of accountability, criminal intent, and predictability were attributed when the contextual information was “hit” as compared to the “harm” and “kill” actions. Furthermore, the greatest difference in accountability and criminal intent scores for the kill action was between the very fast and very slow conditions. These findings raise significant concerns about the use of video evidence in criminal proceedings, as video speed manipulation and contextual information can have a substantial impact on responsibility judgments.
Iris type:
1.1 Articolo in rivista
List of contributors:
Ribatti, Raffaella Maria; Lanciano, Tiziana; De'Sperati, Claudio; Curci, Antonietta
Authors of the University:
DE'SPERATI CLAUDIO
Handle:
https://iris.unisr.it/handle/20.500.11768/176136
Full Text:
https://iris.unisr.it//retrieve/handle/20.500.11768/176136/263060/Ribatti%20et%20al%202024%20(CP).pdf
Published in:
CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY
Journal
  • Overview

Overview

URL

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12144-024-06232-w
  • Use of cookies

Powered by VIVO | Designed by Cineca | 26.11.1.0